[BNDEB #57]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:33 am Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> Please inform this ignorant Anglais... How in your opinion, your personal
SS> opinion, are they a distinct and unique society?
M>
M> Language alone is Unique enough for them to qualify...
Well, let's put it another way... *IF* we must classify Quebec as a distinct
and unique
[BNDEB #58]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:33 am Tue Nov 7, 1995
M> yes but i am speaking truth...they have no clue what is going on..yet speak
M> anyways..with Quite in my mind Hick remarks...
SS>
SS> It may well be so... but it doesn't mean you have to reply...
M>
M> am i supposed to sit there and watch them insult and speak of what they kno
[BNDEB #59]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:33 am Tue Nov 7, 1995
M> they are all also on the NO side..with slight differences in How Parizeau
M> should go about his business..but i'll be in Montreal New Years..and i'll se
M> first hand the situation there...from alot of my relatives as well...
So, out of simple curiousity... Were you born in
[BNDEB #60]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:33 am Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> would have contacted head office and lodged a formal complaint. People
SS> working in a burger are expected to be polite to everyone whether they are
SS> French, Chinese, German speaking tourists - who knows. the person should ha
SS> been fired and you should have gotten invo
[BNDEB #62]
From Silicon Soul to Servility on 7:33 am Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> hehe... I think we're usually in agreement about Most things more often tha
SS> not... &-)
S>
S> Thank god.. I would have some pretty sore fingers otherwise...
Yeah well... you are usually the cause of me spending hours on this thing
typing away... missing my favourite TV pr
[BNDEB #64]
From Servility to Silicon Soul on 12:49 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> Yeah well... you are usually the cause of me spending hours on this thing
SS> typing away... missing my favourite TV programs... losing my sleep... havin
SS> no time to BBS or anything else :) You and your 'cutting edge' debating
SS> questions to get everyone all worked up...
[BNDEB #65]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
R> Shouldn't all the seperatists be dragged out into the street and shot?
M>
M> not necessarily...i'm TOTALLY on the NO side...but the Yes have a
M> point...anyone who wants to argue it BRING IT ON!!! i'm in the debating
M> mood!!!
T> I VOTE YES. This way we will never have to li
[BNDEB #66]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
T> Fucking crock of SHIT. They get better treatment then other provinces, the
T> industires are protected (like dairy) they MADE us put in french as a
T> second official language, we MUST have french/english stuff just incase
T> any quebecers HAPPEN to visit someplace and they on
[BNDEB #67]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
M> again the southern ontarion hick mentality showing through...If you wanna
M> debate back up what your saying
T> NO. poitn is quebec is trying to say "WE ARE MORE EQUAL THEN OTHERS" do
T> we have chinese as a second language NOOOO, even though there are alot of
T> them in canad
[BNDEB #68]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
T> Neither does that example of drinking qualify, THAT YOU CAN'T change, an
T> the referendum would have had NO IMPACT on that, I think he means
T> something a little more then just that language thing, you can't force eith
T> side to change their language. How have they been tre
[BNDEB #69]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
M> you were the minority laguage in Canada...would you can change your language
M> think not...
G>
G> finally!.. an intelligent post about quebec!! BRAVO! BRAVO! :)
M>
M> Thank god i'm not the ONLY non-redneck hick around here :) looks like we'll
M> have fun beating them all off
[BNDEB #70]
From Temujin to Phylon on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
I> I agree... And every year, the seperatists gain more support... I think it i
I> inevitable that Quebec will leave Canada, so I think that they should leave
I> soon.
P>
P> There we go.. :) I dunno how much tax $$$ this referendum cost, but it
P> was ALOT.. they're not helping t
[BNDEB #71]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
T> that and quebecers are very bitter towards english speaking people (some of
T> the quebecers).
P>
P> No crap! everywhere you go in ontario someone speaks french or
P> understands it most of the time, but Quebec! like No-ONE understands english
P> if you goto Montreal about 75%
[BNDEB #72]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS>
SS> On the contrary - 99% of French Quebecois DO speak English. Have always spo
SS> English. And refuse to speak English and consequently are destroying touri
SS> in that province. If they hear you speaking say German amongst yourselves a
SS> then you ask them questions in En
[BNDEB #73]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> Not only that, a separate Quebec is NOT financially viable if they assume
SS> their legitimate portion of the national debt. The ONLY WAY they can surviv
SS> is to renege on their responsibility and leave the rest of Canada holding t
SS> bag, which is exactly what Parizeau in
[BNDEB #74]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> No, they don;t get equal treatment - they get MORE than equal treatment. An
SS> like a child give it an inch it wants a mile! They have more concessions th
SS> any other province in Canada. They run their own pension plan, hospital pla
SS> immigration, they collect their own
[BNDEB #75]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
M> where the hell are you getting this? thin air?...i was saying that there IS
M> people who will refuse to speak french to a only french speaking person even
M> if they speak french...if you seriously don't speak french, no problem...but
M> most of the time the person is able to
[BNDEB #76]
From Temujin to Silicon Soul on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> Put up or shut up... WHAT broken promises etc.etc. etc. pray tell? What
SS> problems other than those of their own creation?
M>
M> problems from English Relations...Problems with Unfair Gov't, Problems with
M> not being heard seeing as they are a minority, want any more?
SS>
[BNDEB #77]
From Temujin to Silicon Soul on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> There are many countries in the world where the populations are quite evenl
SS> divided as to original language, but very few actual bi-lingual countries
SS> where the other languages are recognized officially. Most countries prefer
SS> unity.
Speaking of that Doesn't switzer
[BNDEB #78]
From Temujin to Silicon Soul on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> The trouble wth the French Canadian in general is that they suffer from a
SS> massive inferiority complex that can only be assuaged by assuming these
SS> ridiculous arrogant postures and demanding better than everyone else status
M>
M> your obviously one of the uneducated you
[BNDEB #79]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> I have seen it happen. I have tried to get a phone number and had some
SS> ignorant bitch refuse to answer in English... etc. So am I then to assume t
SS> you are a 'wronged' French Canadian Molson? Or that your parents are?
SS>
SS> If that is the case I have just one very si
[BNDEB #80]
From Temujin to Molson on 4:59 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> There are many countries in the world where the populations are quite evenl
SS> divided as to original language, but very few actual bi-lingual countries
SS> where the other languages are recognized officially. Most countries prefer
SS> unity.
M>
M> might very well be, it pro
[BNDEB #82]
From Gus to Silicon Soul on 7:11 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
G> the indians have the distinct society status.. why can't the quebecers??
SS>
SS> Simple. The North American natives ARE a distinct society. The Quebecois ar
SS> not.
your right.. 7 million people who speak french in a country of 30 million
english speaking people.. your right
[BNDEB #83]
From Gus to Silicon Soul on 7:11 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
G> i think people are forgetting that there are a LOT of french people in the
G> rest of canada..
SS>
SS> I don;t think we're forgetting that at all. At least they aren't busy causi
SS> problems for the country the way their counterparts in la belle province ar
SS> :) Obviously T
[BNDEB #84]
From Gus to Molson on 7:11 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
G> you and almost everyone else on this net would give them the cold shoulder a
G> you are doing it right now..
M>
M> except me :) hehe i think we're losing this debate eh? oh well...maybe they'
M> re-think there opinions eventually...
whatever.. i'm getting tired of all this ar
[BNDEB #85]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:17 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> The French speaking population in Quebec may well end up by getting rid of
SS> large number of 'ethnics' who obviously feel under the gun right now, and o
SS> course a number of English as well. Unfortunately, with them will go the
SS> companies and businesses they have built
[BNDEB #86]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:17 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
SS> Nor do they demand that we use their language in all advertising, governmen
SS> documents, nor do they demand that we shave off, say Vancouver Island and c
SS> it New Hong Kong! so they can have their own country.
M>
M> and the English speaking People don't Treat the Asian pe
[BNDEB #87]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:17 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
.·∙Silicon Soul Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 07 Nov 95 07:11:35·∙·.
SS> Please inform this ignorant Anglais... How in your opinion, your personal
SS> opinion, are they a distinct and unique society?
M>
M> Language alone is Unique enough for them to qualify...
SS>
SS> Well, let's
[BNDEB #88]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:17 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
.·∙Silicon Soul Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 07 Nov 95 07:12:35·∙·.
M> yes but i am speaking truth...they have no clue what is going on..yet speak
M> anyways..with Quite in my mind Hick remarks...
SS>
SS> It may well be so... but it doesn't mean you have to reply...
M>
M> am i s
[BNDEB #89]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:17 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
.·∙Silicon Soul Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 07 Nov 95 07:13:47·∙·.
M> they are all also on the NO side..with slight differences in How Parizeau
M> should go about his business..but i'll be in Montreal New Years..and i'll se
M> first hand the situation there...from alot of my re
[BNDEB #90]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:17 pm Tue Nov 7, 1995
.·∙Silicon Soul Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 07 Nov 95 07:14:45·∙·.
SS> would have contacted head office and lodged a formal complaint. People
SS> working in a burger are expected to be polite to everyone whether they are
SS> French, Chinese, German speaking tourists - who knows
[BNDEB #92]
From Molson to Temujin on 2:18 am Wed Nov 8, 1995
T> If you seriously belive that FRENCH would remain a second language you are
T> LARGE time mistaken, if quebec had got a yes vote and was leaving, next
T> federal election we would see the axing of the second french language as a
T> campaign promise. WE ONLY HAVE the damn thing
[BNDEB #93]
From Molson to Temujin on 2:18 am Wed Nov 8, 1995
M> Again...think about what your gonnna say before you say it...and make sure
M> what your saying is true...seeing as that wasn't...
T> The milk thing i'm not sure of.
T>
T> But the bitter attitude on both sides towards the other DOES EXIST and your
T> fooling yourself. I mean wh
[BNDEB #94]
From Molson to Temujin on 2:18 am Wed Nov 8, 1995
T> Okay, they have their language as a second language, well its equal to
T> english. Hmmm I REALLY don't see any difference between how THEY ARE
T> TREATED to how I am, or other people i know. The ONLY problem i see is
T> them bitching about wanting to retain their language, pro
[BNDEB #95]
From Molson to Temujin on 2:18 am Wed Nov 8, 1995
.·∙Temujin Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 07 Nov 95 16:50:30·∙·.
SS> There are many countries in the world where the populations are quite evenl
SS> divided as to original language, but very few actual bi-lingual countries
SS> where the other languages are recognized officially. M
[BNDEB #96]
From Molson to Gus on 2:18 am Wed Nov 8, 1995
.·∙Gus Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 07 Nov 95 16:34:12·∙·.
G> you and almost everyone else on this net would give them the cold shoulder a
G> you are doing it right now..
M>
M> except me :) hehe i think we're losing this debate eh? oh well...maybe they'
M> re-think there opinion
[BNDEB #100]
From Grandpa to Gus on 7:27 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
G> i think people are forgetting that there are a LOT of french people in the
G> rest of canada..
I think people are forgetting the the English and French had a war, and they
lost.
Yours Truly
Grandpa
* Origin: +%+ The Tide - 28.8k Node 1 - 1.93Gigs (2662:519/140)
[BNDEB #101]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:27 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
SS> AS I was trying to explain - most of their problems, they bring upon
SS> themselves.
M>
M> well yes...but you have to remeber they WERE provoked to start the whole thi
M> from the beginning...so it is all not Totally there own fault..
I wasn't aware of the provocation... How
[BNDEB #102]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:27 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
M> true...but if you take a look..Quebec is the MOST different from anything el
M> combined in Canada...There is no other place with such a difference in
M> language, etc...then quebec...
Well, I don;t agree that language is everything. Far from it. It is simply a
means of commu
[BNDEB #104]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:27 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
M> you think Quebec is the only place where people speak french? hahaah think
M> not..it WOULD still HAVE to be french as a second laguage...becuase even
M> without quebec....french is sTILL the second laguage..
Oh, I think if Quebec went it's merry way, it would be a very short
[BNDEB #105]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:27 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
M> of course theres tension on both sides..i never said there wasn't...i just
M> said that alot of it was provoked by the english speaking part..
You keep saying we provoke them... HOW do we/did we provoke them? By giving in
to just about everything they've ever demanded?
Becau
[BNDEB #106]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:27 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
M> why? the french settlement was PROMISED that they would be able to retain
M> there language when taken over...and if you say ONLY native canadians can
And they certainly have retqained their language! To the EXCLUSION of English!
in that province. It is illegal! for a restaura
[BNDEB #107]
From Silicon Soul to Molson on 7:27 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
M> Spanish is there official second language..so maybe AGAIN you should read
M> before you speak..
Spanish is NOT written into their constitution! SPANISH is NOT guaranteed.
Like the man said it is just 'There'. And only in those states like Californai
and Texas where they have
[BNDEB #108]
From Temujin to Molson on 7:44 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
T> If you seriously belive that FRENCH would remain a second language you are
T> LARGE time mistaken, if quebec had got a yes vote and was leaving, next
T> federal election we would see the axing of the second french language as a
T> campaign promise. WE ONLY HAVE the damn thing
[BNDEB #109]
From Temujin to Molson on 7:44 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
T> Okay, they have their language as a second language, well its equal to
T> english. Hmmm I REALLY don't see any difference between how THEY ARE
T> TREATED to how I am, or other people i know. The ONLY problem i see is
T> them bitching about wanting to retain their language, pro
[BNDEB #110]
From Temujin to Molson on 7:44 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
SS> unity.
M>
M> might very well be, it probably would have been easier to force english on
M> them from the start, and it's WAY to late to do anything now...
M>
M> Acually the U.S. has 2 official languages...and they seem to do fine...Engli
M> and Spanish...
T> Spanish is NOT an
[BNDEB #111]
From Temujin to Silicon Soul on 7:44 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
M> Spanish is there official second language..so maybe AGAIN you should read
M> before you speak..
SS>
SS> Spanish is NOT written into their constitution! SPANISH is NOT guaranteed.
SS> Like the man said it is just 'There'. And only in those states like Califor
SS> and Texas wher
[BNDEB #112]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:36 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
.·∙Silicon Soul Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 08 Nov 95 14:46:55·∙·.
SS> AS I was trying to explain - most of their problems, they bring upon
SS> themselves.
M>
M> well yes...but you have to remeber they WERE provoked to start the whole thi
M> from the beginning...so it is all no
[BNDEB #113]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:36 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
.·∙Silicon Soul Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 08 Nov 95 14:51:33·∙·.
M> true...but if you take a look..Quebec is the MOST different from anything el
M> combined in Canada...There is no other place with such a difference in
M> language, etc...then quebec...
SS>
SS> Well, I don;t a
[BNDEB #115]
From Molson to Silicon Soul on 8:36 pm Wed Nov 8, 1995
.·∙Silicon Soul Blurted this to Molson
`∙·On 08 Nov 95 14:59:52·∙·.
M> of course theres tension on both sides..i never said there wasn't...i just
M> said that alot of it was provoked by the english speaking part..
SS>
SS> You keep saying we provoke them... HOW do we/did we provo